Keep in mind that I've ranked these particular shows not in terms of their overall quality but rather in terms of their humor content. Often, the two go hand in hand, but some of the shows here listed aren't primarily known as comedies, although they may contain a considerable amount of humor. That explains why certain magnificent shows (e.g. My Fair Lady, The Fantasticks) might not be ranked as high as some other shows that are not quite as good but are considerably more funny.
- A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum
- The Book of Mormon
- Avenue Q
- Guys and Dolls
- The Drowsy Chaperone
- How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying
- Little Shop of Horrors
- Urinetown
- Little Me
- Xanadu
- The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
- Bat Boy
- City of Angels
- The Producers
- Hairspray
- [title of show]
- Spamalot
- They're Playing Our Song
- Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson
- The Full Monty
- A Day in Hollywood/A Night in the Ukraine
- Hello, Dolly!
- Anything Goes
- Chicago
- The Music Man
- Kiss Me Kate
- The Great American Trailer Park Musical
- Animal Crackers
- A Chorus Line
- Damn Yankees
- Fiddler on the Roof
- Into the Woods
- Falsettos
- La Cage aux Folles
- The Pajama Game
- Sweet Charity
- Wonderful Town
- Finian's Rainbow
- My Fair Lady
- Altar Boyz
- The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas
- As Thousands Cheer
- Dirty Rotten Scoundrels
- Grease
- On the Town
- 1776
- Of Thee I Sing
- Li'L Abner
- Me and My Girl
- My Favorite Year
- Ruthless!
- No, No, Nanette
- On the 20th Century
- Once Upon a Mattress
- When Pigs Fly
- Annie Get Your Gun
- Promises Promises
- Strike Up the Band
- The Boys From Syracuse
- The Pirates of Penzance
- The Rocky Horror Show
- 42nd Street
- Annie
- Gutenberg - the Musical
- High Button Shoes
- A Connecticut Yankee
- The Boyfriend
- Pippin
- Where's Charley?
- Pins and Needles
- Mame
- Gentlemen Prefer Blondes
- She Loves Me
- Victor/Victoria
- A Little Night Music
- The Mikado
- The Wedding Singer
- Legally Blonde
- The Wiz
- Candide
- The Sound of Music
- Bye Bye Birdie
- Rock of Ages
- Reefer Madness
- Little Mary Sunshine
- The Marvelous Wonderettes
- Dames at Sea
- The Toxic Avenger Musical
- The Fantasticks
- Ernest in Love
- Nunsense
- Olympus on My Mind
- What's That Smell: The Music of Jacob Sterling
- The Musical of Musicals - The Musical
- Forever Plaid
- Lucky Stiff
- The Kid
- Hedwig and the Angry Inch
- Xanna, Don't
- You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown
- Whoop De Doo
- Evil Dead - The Musical
Honorable Mention: Forbidden Broadway - Why haven't I listed it above? Because it has so many different versions. Which one was the funniest? That's another post entirely.
